Empathetic rats stir controversy

In an Oct 19 post, I discussed some fascinating published and unpublished studies on rodent empathy. This week, a new article on the topic appeared in Science, which evoked a commentary in the Washington Post, as well as comments in the Society of Neuroscience blogosphere. Inbal Ben-Ami Bartal and colleagues at the U of Chicago established a paradigm in which a freely moving rat is placed in a cage with another rat that is trapped in a transparent plastic restrainer. The restrainer has a lever that opens a door, allowing the restrained rat to escape into the cage with the free rat. After several sessions moving around the restrainer, the free rat accidentally opens the door, allowing the trapped rat to come out. In subsequent sessions, the freely moving rat opens the door to liberate the trapped rat very quickly. A video of this test can be found here. The freely moving rat does not open the container when it is empty or when it contains a novel object rather than a rat. The free rat also opens the restrainer even when it is prevented from subsequent contact with the trapped rat. Interestingly, all 6 of the female rats tested learned to open the captive’s cage, but 7 of the 26 males tested never did. Does this mean that the males are less empathetic, or that they learn the task less well? Or that they did not bump into the lever in the first place? The senior author on the paper, Peggy Mason, thinks that the males may not have the ability to down-regulate their own stress in order to act on their empathetic impulses.

In a further test, a second container was placed in the cage, and the freely moving rat was given the opportunity to open one containing chocolate chips and/or the one containing the trapped rat. Perhaps surprisingly, the free rat opens both containers and even shares some of the chocolate with the newly freed rat.

Regarding the interpretation of the results, some neuroscientists disagree with the idea of empathy here, preferring the notion that the free rat lets the trapped rat out in order to end its own stress rather than the stress experienced by the trapped rat. My own opinion is that this is a false dichotomy. Humans feel stress when they see someone else in stress, and they probably try to release the stress in both parties.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Empathetic rats stir controversy

  1. darioringach says:

    “Humans feel stress when they see someone else in stress, and they probably try to release the stress in both parties.”

    The difficulty is that the free rat did not have an option to release the stress in itself by leaving the arena and the other rat trapped, for example. Here we discuss these findings in some more detail.

    http://speakingofresearch.com/2011/12/14/empathy-and-altruism-in-rats/

    • phpatterson says:

      Thx Dario. Thinking of the human situation again, when we are confronted with someone in stress, I think we too sometimes take the easy way out and leave – as in not stopping to help a motorist in trouble even tho we feel sorry for him/her. Thus, I don’t think offering the free rat a choice between releasing the trapped rat or running away from the stressful situation would distinguish rat from human empathy.

  2. Blackheart says:

    Perhaps the answer lies in a survival advantage for the ‘free rat’ …

    Female rats may be more concerned with breeding and the food provision the male rat may bring in a more ‘natural’ environment.
    Male rats may be more concerned with competition over resources or it may have depended on the social position of the trapped rat.

  3. Please so not stop updating your site. I just found it and it is fascinating info!
    I don’t comment a lot, but I read every article.

    Thank you for your blog!

    • phpatterson says:

      Excellent Kitty – thx v much.
      I’ve been in India for 2 wks for a mtg of the International Society of Developmental Neurobiology. Will try to update blog soon after returning. Cheers, PHP

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s